✦
open enrollment

Open Enrollment Math: Pick Your 2027 Health Plan on Total Cost

The premium is the number you see first and usually the least useful one. Here is how to compare the total annual cost of 2027 health plans before open enrollment closes.

Open Enrollment Math: Pick Your 2027 Health Plan on Total Cost

The premium is the number you see first

The cheapest premium can still be the most expensive plan.

The premium is the figure printed on the enrollment page, and it is usually the least useful one for predicting what you will spend. Your real annual cost has three parts: what you pay in premiums, what you pay out of pocket before insurance takes over, and the ceiling on that second number. Open enrollment is the one window to compare all three side by side, and most people compare only the first. Two plans with similar premiums can produce very different bills in a bad year. The deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum sit lower on the page, usually in the same table, and they decide what a surgery, a broken ankle, or a year of specialist visits actually costs you.

Run the numbers on two illustrative plans

The plans below are invented for the arithmetic and are not quotes from any insurer. Plan A is a PPO with a $350 monthly premium ($4,200 a year), a $500 deductible, 20 percent coinsurance after the deductible, and a $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum. Plan B is a high-deductible plan with a $290 monthly premium ($3,480 a year), a $2,000 deductible, 20 percent coinsurance, and an $8,000 out-of-pocket maximum. In a year with no covered care beyond routine preventive visits, Plan B costs $3,480 and Plan A costs $4,200, so Plan B saves $720. In a year with $15,000 in covered bills, Plan A charges $500 plus 20 percent of the remaining $14,500, which is $3,400, for a total of $7,600 with premiums included. Plan B charges $2,000 plus 20 percent of the remaining $13,000, which is $4,600, for a total of $8,080. The cheaper premium loses by $480 in that year.

The gap widens in the worst case. At $40,000 in covered bills, Plan A stops at its $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum, so the total is $8,200. Plan B stops at $8,000, so the total is $11,480. That is a $3,280 difference in the worst year, against a $720 difference in the best one. The premium saving is real, but it is small next to the ceiling you accept in exchange for it.

Read the summary of benefits, not the brochure

Every plan publishes a summary of benefits and coverage, and it is the document that tells you what the premium cannot. Read it with a pencil and check four things before you rank any two plans.

  • Whether the deductible is per person or per family, and whether the family deductible is embedded inside the family out-of-pocket maximum.
  • Which drugs you take, and which formulary tier each one sits in, since a specialty drug can cost more than the deductible in a single fill.
  • Whether your current doctors and the hospital you would use are in network.
  • What the plan charges for emergency care and urgent care visits, which often sit outside the routine copay schedule.

Prescription costs are the item most people skip, and they are the one that can flip the ranking. A plan with a higher premium and a low copay on your medication can beat a cheap plan that puts the same drug behind the deductible. Check the drug list before you check the deductible.

Out-of-network care is where the summary tends to surprise people. A plan may cover an out-of-network specialist, but at a higher coinsurance and sometimes with a separate deductible, and the bills may not count toward the same out-of-pocket maximum. If you already see a specialist you like, ask the insurer to confirm the network status and the cost-sharing in writing before you rely on that relationship for the year.

Where the HSA changes the comparison

If you pick a high-deductible plan, the premium is not the only number that moves. Contributions made through payroll skip income and payroll taxes, which makes them cheaper than the same dollars deposited after the fact, as long as your employer offers that route. Check whether your employer contributes to the HSA at all, because an employer deposit changes the comparison before you pay a dollar of premium. Any employer contribution counts against the annual limit, so the two sources of money share one ceiling.

A high-deductible plan qualifies you for a health savings account, and the account changes the math in Plan B's favor. For 2027, the IRS sets the contribution limit at $4,500 for self-only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, according to IRS Revenue Procedure 2026-24 as reported by several benefits sites. Account holders 55 and older can add a $1,000 catch-up. Money you put into the HSA lowers your taxable income, and it can pay the deductible in Plan B without a second tax bill. The HSA is only a shield, though, if the cash is actually there. Without the savings to fund the deductible and the $8,000 ceiling, the lower premium is a bet on a healthy year, not a saving.

Use the health FSA before its clock runs out

A health FSA lets you set aside pre-tax money for deductibles, copays, and prescriptions. The 2026 limit is $3,400 per employee, and the election you make during open enrollment is the amount you can use. The expiration rule is the part that trips people up. A plan can offer a carryover of up to $680 for plan year 2026, or a grace period of up to two months and 15 days into the next year, but not both, according to IRS Notice 2013-71. Check which option your employer offers before you choose the amount, because the answer decides how much of a conservative election is safe. The 2027 carryover cap had not been released when these sources were checked, so confirm the figure with your plan documents.

The strongest move here is the most boring one. Add up the prescriptions, dental work, glasses, and therapy copays you already expect, and elect a little less than that total. Leftover money is the cost of over-electing, and a conservative number avoids it.

Know the enrollment windows for each route

If you buy through HealthCare.gov, open enrollment for 2027 coverage runs from November 1, 2026 through January 15, 2027. Enroll by December 15 and pay the first premium, and coverage starts January 1. Enroll between December 16 and January 15 and coverage starts February 1. Some state exchanges set their own end dates, so check your state's site if you do not use HealthCare.gov. Employer plans run on the employer's calendar, and the HR portal sets the cut-off for those elections. Missing a window usually means waiting for the next one unless a qualifying life event opens a special enrollment period.

Pick the cheap plan only if you can pay its ceiling

Here is the rule the math supports. Choose the high-deductible plan only if you could pay its full out-of-pocket maximum from savings without borrowing, and you would fund the HSA anyway. Otherwise the PPO's higher premium buys a lower worst-case bill, and in the worst-case example above that protection was worth $3,280. If a pregnancy is possible in 2027, weigh the ceiling even more heavily, because prenatal care and delivery can reach a deductible and an out-of-pocket maximum within a single plan year. That is the moment the lower ceiling matters most, and it is the one the premium table never shows.

The cheaper plan on the page is not always the cheaper plan for your year. Run both bills before you tick a box.